Our Story

The Original Brooklyn Pizza

The Original Brooklyn Pizza is an authentic New York–style pizzeria specializing in making a style of pizza characterized by large hand-tossed thin-crust pies, often sold in wide slices to go. It has a crust which is crisp along its edge yet soft enough beneath its toppings to be folded in half to eat.

The first pizzeria in America was founded by Gennaro Lombardi in New York City’s Little Italy in 1905. An immigrant from Naples, he opened a grocery store in 1897. An employee, Antonio Totonno Pero, began making pizza in an altered Neapolitan style, which sold for five cents a pie. Many people, however, could not afford a whole pie and instead would offer what they could in return for a corresponding sized slice, which was wrapped in paper tied with string. In 1924, Totonno left Lombardi’s to open his own pizzeria on Coney Island, called Totonno’s.

Brooklyn Pizza had established itself as a Lexington favorite prior to the closing of its first restaurant and other franchise locations in the area, the last of which was the Keithshire location that closed in 2010.

In 2012, a group of friends, dedicated to the taste, style and tradition previously embraced by Brooklyn Pizza, re-established it as The Original Brooklyn Pizza, and carry on the tradition begun by Mr. Lombardi all those many years ago. In addition to the authentic recipe for pizza, The Original Brooklyn Pizza also provides its customers with other multiple culinary options from sandwiches to salads, cheesecake and cannoli, a host of appetizers as well as a full service bar serving domestic, import and craft beers, wine and other spirits to compliment the many flavors of the restaurant.

We appreciate your spending your time with us and allowing us to serve you what we are confident you will find is “The Original” Brooklyn Pizza.

Welcome to Brooklyn, Y’all!

A Variety of Options

Explore Our Menu


  • Garlic Knots

    SM$3.99 / LG$5.99

    Covered in garlic butter and parmesan cheese with a side of marinara
  • Garlic Cheese Bread


    Covered in garlic butter and mozzarella cheese with a side of marinara
  • Fried Mozzarella


    With a side of marinara
  • Mozzarella Sticks


    11” Pizza Crust covered in homemade garlic butter and mozzarella w/ side of marinara
  • Pickle Chips


    With a side of creamy horseradish
  • Zucchini Frita


    With a side of creamy horseradish


  • Side House/Caesar Salad


    *Ranch, FF Ranch,*Balsamic, Bleu Cheese, *Italian, Honey Mustard, Caesar, & French Extra Dressing $0.59
  • Caprese Salad


    Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil, Roma Tomatoes, & Balsamic Vinaigrette
  • Caesar Salad

    $5.99 / $1.99

    Romaine, Croutons, Grilled Chicken, & Creamy Parmesan Caesar Dressing / Add Anchovies
  • Cobb Salad


    Romaine, Bacon, Eggs, Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Feta, and Black Olives
  • Chef Salad


    House Salad w/ Ham, Salami, & Pepperoni
  • House Salad


    Iceberg, Mozzarella, Banana Peppers, Onions, Black Olives, & Tomatoes

Monday - Friday * 3PM-6PM

Happy Hour




excluding chicken


Thirsty Thursday

Thursdays starting at 9PM enjoy a Second Happy Hour Until Close

Wine Down Wednesday

Wednesdays $10 bottles of wine all day.

$6.99 Lunch Special

Pick two lunch special (Pepperoni Slice, Cheese Slice, Slice of the Day, Side Salad, Side Caesar, Garlic Bread, Side of Meatballs, Side of Fries, Chips) Monday-Friday 11am-3pm

2 For Tuesday

Tuesdays buy an Italian Entree at regular price and get another of equal or lesser value for 1/2 PRICE. Dine in only.

Kid's Night - $1.99

Monday nights all kid's meals are $1.99 drink included. Limit 2 per adult meal. Dine in Only

Feel free to

Contact us